The Continuing Evolution  of the 1911   

The Complete Book of the 1911

page 1  page 2


Click for larger image.
As a backup for an entry job, or a duty gun with the right holster, the Tactical Lite offers a lot of capacity in a compact and relatively lightweight package.
Click for larger image.
Hot ammo and light guns are usually a chore to test. But not the Tactical Lite soaked up recoil a lot better than you'd expect an aluminum-frame would.

When it came to reliability testing, I could have phoned in the results. Were I the type to find range time boring I would have been bored by the testing. I hauled a selection of ammo along, factory hardball and hollow points, some factory lead, a bunch of reloads and a box marked "misc." The Duty One gobbled up everything I had, including the miscellaneous box.

Lest you think I’m feeding an expensive loner gun garbage ammo, the "misc." box is range pickups from law enforcement classes. Invariably, when we go to clean up the range, there is loose ammo lying with the brass. (I run a clean range, and we always police brass.) The ammo is always factory as the price for State Bid ammo is so low no one bothers to bring reloads. But no one is too keen on mixing Remington with Winchester, hardball with hollowpoints, when their department mandates one or the other. Rather than present the brass mill with a problem, we sort out the live stuff. That is the "misc." box. One load I was particularly interested in was the old Speer 200-grain HP load. Back in the day, when we were shooting lots of howling pins, the Speer 200-grain hollowpoint over 6.3 grains of WW-231 was the load of choice. But I have heard from some using their dwindling supply (Speer no longer makes the bullet--the machine wore out) that the load was not always reliable in a ramped-barrel gun. Not so with the Duty One.
 
Click for larger image.
This Tactical Lite came in the popular .40 S&W, but you can have it in 9x19mm and .45 ACP as well.

As for accuracy, the Duty One had plenty. I shot it over sandbags at 15 yards. (I would have done so at 25, but all the ranges were set up for a match, and I didn’t want to move anything and cause problems for the chief range officer.) At that distance the Duty One would easily shoot one- to two-inch groups, which is about what I can do while fully caffeinated and after hauling my gear down from the parking lot.

While more accuracy is better, you could easily find a tackdriving load from the factory for defense, duty or qualification. Once again, the Oregon Trails 200-grain lead bullet and Vihtavuori 310 load was the most accurate. I’m convinced that if you have a gun that won’t shoot accurately with anything else, it will shoot with this load. And if it doesn’t shoot with this load, it needs some work.

After accuracy testing I spent a relaxing afternoon hammering the plate rack, our various pepper poppers and trying a few drills. At no time did the Duty One give me the slightest problem. If I did not already have a couple of shelves of the safe packed with reliable and accurate 1911s, I might ask Dave what he wants for this one. As it is, I’ll just have to send it back.
 
Click for larger image.
The difference between a 126mm magazines and a 140 isn't much. But in competition, and defense, having a couple more rounds can be vital. In 9x19 and .38 Super, the Tactical Lite packs 18 rounds into flush magazines.

Not everyone can use a .45. Some departments don’t allow it. Some even mandate a particular caliber and load. (Detroit, for instance requires use of .40 S&W with a 180-grain FMJ bullet, perhaps the most overpenetrative combination extant.) Some shooters want more capacity than a single stack can deliver, and others want to save a little bit of weight. The Tactical Lite model Dave sent me is built on the high-capacity STI frame with an aluminum receiver, Commander length and with a light rail machined into the dustcover.

At 29 ounces empty, the Tactical is noticeably lighter than the Duty One. With its (now legal) hi-cap magazine, it holds 16 rounds of .40 S&W, 15 in the magazine and one in the chamber. The slide, like that of the Duty One, has a Heinie slant rear, dovetail front and a flat on top. Unlike the Duty One, the Tactical does not have front grasping grooves, and the slide is full profile out to the muzzle. There are no recoil-spring tunnel scallops on this slide. The barrel is a coned bull barrel with integral feed ramp.

While the integral ramp is useful but not always needed in .45, in .40 it is essential. Where the .45 operates at 17,000 PSI, the 40 operates at twice that pressure. A weak case from a commercial reload or the one-in-a-million overpressure factory load could blow a .40 case. While a blown .45 is cause for gun cleaning and a new magazine, the extra pressure of the .40 often trashes a gun, with few salvageable parts. Underneath the barrel, the slide is cycled via a Recoilmaster recoil-spring, dual-spring assembly. The extractor is a standard 1911.
 
Click for larger image.
Dave Skinner has a wicked sense of humor. Here is his special accessory for tactical-railed guns (he must have seen an 1837 Elgin Cutlass Pistol)

The dustcover extends to the end of the slide, and the slabside slide lacks recoil-spring scallop cuts. In appearance it bears a resemblance to the original model 1900 that Browning designed and Colt made. While the Tactical is lighter than the Duty One, the extra weight of the slide puts the balance forward of where it would otherwise be. The thumb safety is an ambi, and I have no problems with it banging against my knuckle. The hi-cap frames sit just enough different in my hand that the safety-bump issue I have with single-stack guns doesn’t exist. The grip safety is the standard STI unit, with knuckle scallops and speed bump. The frame on the grips and magazine portion is a synthetic unit bolted to the aluminum frame rails and barrel cut section. The grip has cast-in checkering while the aluminum mainspring housing has machined checkering.

The Tactical Lite comes in 9mm, .40 or .45; your choice of plain, fiber optic or tritium night sights; and the same black polymer-coat finish on the slide and type II anodizing on the frame that everyone else gets. You can get a Commander or Government-length slide.
 
Click for larger image.
The Duty One is soft in recoil.
Click for larger image.
The test-fire volunteers never fail to show up for free ammo. Who can blame the?
Click for larger image.
The mag funnels locks my hands in place when I'm using glove. IPSC competition has driven this modification.
Click for larger image.
The 126mm magazine disappears into the mag well.

 

 

 

 

At the bottom of the frame we run into the one feature most likely to bring howls of outrage to the tactical set: a magazine funnel. "Not kosher," some would say, and others would object to it on the grounds that it can’t be concealed. On the other hand, I have talked to officers on raids who expended all the ammunition in their weapon and had to reload. At the moment they needed a reload, anything that would have made it faster and more certain would have been welcomed. If you really have to conceal it, then take it off. All you need to do is drift out the mainspring housing pin, remove the funnel, and replace the pin with a standard-length pin. Done.

Considering the amount of gear an entry officer already has and the bulkiness of it all, a magazine funnel isn’t going to be noticed, nor is it likely to get hung up on a door or window. And I find that the magazine funnel is well positioned to act as a brace against the bottom edges of my hands. With a pair of nomex gloves on, the Tactical (or any STI with a funnel) is practically locked to my hands and doesn’t go anywhere under recoil.

And recoil is what you’re going to get if you feed this lightweight blaster top-end ammo. While standard practice reloaded ammo or factory hardball were sedate, the hotter stuff was quite a handful. The new Cor-Bon Powrball comes back right smart into your hands but is easy to control once you realize it isn’t going to hurt. (I’ve shot handguns that hurt to fire. Fun is fun, but those weren’t.) As for accuracy, the Tactical matched its bigger brother for groups. I found it easy to punch two-inch groups with it, and when the force was with me and the wind wasn’t making the target stand dance, I could get groups down almost to an inch. It never failed to work with any ammo I had brought--a collection of hardball, hollowpoints and softpoints.

The Recoilmaster dual-spring recoil system does a good job of soaking up the recoil generated by hot loads, and you might be fooled by how soft the standard loads feel--you may think you’ve got some wimpy practice ammo instead of the full-power stuff. The now-standard magazines will hold 15 rounds of .40 S&W. If you send them off to a wizard like Dave Dawson, he can tune and adjust them to hold 17 rounds. If you go up in size from the flush-fit 126mm magazines to USPSA Limited-class 140mm magazines, you can have tuned magazines that will hold 19 or 20 rounds. In other calibers the flush magazines will hold 18 rounds of 9mm or .38 Super or 13 rounds of .45. Again, with tuning you can get one or two more.

But what are they for, and how can you carry them? The simple answer is that they are for shooters who feel the need to have a light-rail option. For tactical use, or uniform carry where the department allows single-action pistols, either of these and a tactical light would be very useful. While it may be a bit of a struggle to find a duty holster that fits one of these, fits departmental holster regs and looks good, tactical officers have no such problems. (A duty holster will almost certainly have the light off the sidearm when carried.)

London Bridge Trading Company makes a thigh rig for light-mounted sidearms. Either would fit, no problem. And if you wanted to carry with the light someplace else, any holster it makes would hold these sans light. Blackhawk also makes holsters to fit either light-mounted or -dismounted railed sidearms.

And for those looking for a competition gun, you’d be hard-pressed to find one better out of the box. Now, you won’t be allowed to use either of these in an IDPA match, but no one will give you a second look (unless you’ve practiced and are doing well) shooting one of these at a USPSA/IPSC match. For pins, steel and just impressing the heck out of the guys at the local club during the monthly match, an STI tactical gun goes a long way.
 
 Magazines
I had one of my test crew comment, "The Duty One ships with one mag? What’s up with that?" Well, there is no lack of reliable single-stack magazines available. In the old days we’d worry about magazines, but today finding good ones is as easy as falling out of bed. I tried the Metalform the Duty One came with and a collection of Wilson, McCormick, Novak, Ed Brown and unknown magazines I have on hand. All worked. So, why should STI ship you extra magazines that it would have to charge you for when you may well have settled on another brand as your dependable supply?

And the Tactical, shipping with a magazine marked "LEO/Export Only"? Now that the Assault Weapons Ban is history, the markings mean nothing. Except for readers who live in benighted People’s Republics where state law still bans hi-caps, we can all own what we want again. And the markings simply mean they were made then, but not banned now. I expect in some distant future that magazine collectors will try to track down old LEO-Only marked magazines to fill their collections. But for now, it simply is a curiosity and a reminder that a week
before I  had it, having that magazine would have been a felony. Some readers question the wisdom of possessing something marked "LEO-Only" in case some overly ambitious or under-educated back-woods officer sees it and attempts an arrest based on ‘stolen police property." Maybe, for a week or two after the ban sunset. But by now word has spread to all that the markings are meaningless. If you’re worried, save this article, and point it out to the officer, desk sergeant and shift commander. But then, if it gets as high as the shift commander, you’ve probably got a good case for a suit for false arrest brewing. More likely, if you do get stopped, a quick phone call or radio call to the station will clear up things.

That said, should you have your magazines tuned for extra capacity? My approach would be no, not unless you find the magazine unreliable as-is. The tuned competition magazines can be a bit more touchy about reliable feeding when treated to harsh conditions. I’d rather have the extra reliability margin than the extra round or two.

 

 CHRONOGRAPH RESULTS
STI Duty One vs. Commander, .45 ACP
Brand and Load (grs) Duty One Commander
Remington Golden Saber 230867 816
Remington Golden Saber 185995 923
PMP 220 JRN 872 837
Black Hills 230 JRN 767 727
PMC 230 JRN 806 779
Zero 185 JHP 870 824
Hornady 200 XTP 893 852
Speer Gold Dot 230 842 823
W-W Ranger SXT 230 856 833
Black Hills 185 JHP 981 953
Montana Gold 185 JHP/6.O Titegroup 952 904
Rainier 230 P-RN/4.6 Titegroup 744 713
STI Tactical Lite, .40 S&W
Black Hills 180 JF 976  
Black Hills 180 JH 971  
Federal Hydra-Shok 16 948  
Cor-Bon 135 PowRBall 1,246  
W-W White Box 180 JFP 846  
Remington Golden Saber 180 890  
Velocities measured in feet per second 15 feet from muzzle
 Source
STI International
Dept. GNHG 114 Halmar Cove,
Georgetown, TX 78628
(512) 819-0656 www.stiguns.com

page 1  page 2


STI - Designed to Perform    

Please report any problems with this page to our webmaster.

 

All items Copyright © 2005 STI International, Inc.
STI, STI International, and the STI Swirl are registered trademarks of STI International, Inc.


Web site design and management by Kevin J. Solito